When a former U.S. president's son, Ron Reagan, contended
at the Democratic National Convention in Boston last month
that "the theology of a few is harming the health of the
many," he could have been speaking about global AIDS rather
than stem-cell research.
At the 15th International AIDS Congress in Bangkok, it was
evident that theological taboos have contributed to the
escalating HIV/AIDS crisis. At a time when more than 40
million worldwide are infected, nearly 50 percent of them
women, the religious roots of this disease must be examined to
determine how the theological thinking of some has caused
widespread harm to many.
These theological taboos include not talking openly about
sex, preventing people from understanding how to prevent the
disease. Second, moralistic judgments toward infected persons
and their families have added to society's stigmatization.
Third, religious prejudice toward sex workers, injection-drug
users, gay men and others has contributed to discrimination.
Silence, stigma and discrimination keep people from getting
tested and treated.
"The theology of a few" has unfortunately long influenced
many religious responses to the world's worst health crisis.
Patriarchal religious assumptions have made women especially
vulnerable. Endless controversies over the efficacy of condoms
have helped deny people the least expensive "weapon of mass
protection" available. In many countries, married women and
young girls are endangered because they lack education and
control of their own sex lives.
Some religious communities have done pioneering work in the
battle against HIV and AIDS, but often their sacrificial
service has been obscured by the publicity given to the
religious right's twisted theology claiming that "AIDS is the
punishment of God." This has prompted people to embrace a
theology of condemnation rather than compassion, indifference
rather than involvement. Instead of offering a theology of
hope and health, faith-based groups sometimes have become
missionaries of death, not life.
Twenty plus years into the pandemic, faith-based groups
belatedly emerged at this year's conference demonstrating
their willingness to participate in positive partnership with
others engaged in efforts at education, prevention, care and
treatment. Never before had people of faith from the world's
major religions met together to face the world escalation of
the AIDS pandemic -- a confluence that Dr. Peter Piot, UNAIDS
executive director, said sketched a vision of his hopes.
Piot declared, "I hope for a day when every church engages
in an open dialogue on issues of sexuality and gender
difference. I hope for a day when every synagogue will
mobilize as advocates for a global response to find AIDS, when
every temple will fully welcome people living with HIV, where
every mosque is a place where young people will learn about
the facts of HIV and
AIDS."
"When that will have happened," concluded Piot, "I am
convinced that nothing will stop our success in our fight
against AIDS."
Piot's audience, however, knew that this day has not yet
dawned, primarily because a "theology of a few" continues to
dominate the hierarchical leadership of many faith
communities.
I have argued that the "theology of the few" dare not
continue to dominate either religious responses or government
policy. Faith-based groups - - Muslim, Christian, Jewish,
Buddhist, or Hindu -- share common core values of compassion,
love and human dignity. Embedded in all the great religions is
sacred text equivalent to the Torah's promise that "when you
save the life of one person, you save the world."
Just as attitudinal and behavioral change are essential
steps in AIDS prevention for individuals, it is imperative
that faith-based groups change certain beliefs and behavior so
they can provide a message of hope, services of loving care
and a theology of life.
Donald E. Messer (dmesser@iliff.edu) is
author of "Breaking The Conspiracy of Silence: Christian
Churches and the Global AIDS Crisis" (Fortress, 2004) and a
professor at the Iliff School of Theology in Denver, where he
directs the Center for the Church and Global AIDS.